5 Things I Wish I Knew Before Building My Squarespace Website

I am giving a honest and experienced based advice to small business owners, coaches and creatives who want to a website that actually works.

It took me three weekends to complete my first Squarespace website. The website was decent having clean layout, modern fonts and responsive design. I was proud of my first work. As sometime past, I visited Google Search Console six months later and found only eleven people visited my website organically.

I was shocked after seeing these results and then I started searching the reason, why it was happening? It was happening due to 05 reasons which I am going to explain below. About 90% people repeat these mistakes before publishing their website.

1.    Squarespace Will Not Automatically Help You Rank on Google

Let's start with the one that stings the most. Squarespace has done an excellent job positioning itself as an "SEO-friendly" platform. And technically, that's true — it handles a lot of the technical groundwork automatically. It generates sitemaps, creates clean URL structures, produces valid HTML, and makes your site mobile-responsive by default. Compared to a poorly coded custom site from 2009, yes, Squarespace is miles ahead.

But here's what "SEO-friendly" does *not* mean: it does not mean your website will rank.

By analyzing over one billion web pages found that 90% of all pages get zero organic traffic from Google — and the majority of those pages weren't broken or poorly designed. The reasons were: -

• They simply had no backlinks.
• Does not had targeted keyword strategy.
• Content that didn't address what real users were searching for.
•  Platform choice was barely a factor.

Squarespace gives you the infrastructure. You still have to do the work.

What that actually looks like in practice:

Page titles matter more than you think. Your homepage title should not be your business name. It should be your business name plus what you do plus where you do it. "Sarah's Coaching" tells Google nothing. "Life Coach for Overwhelmed Moms | Online & Houston, TX" tells Google everything it needs.

Page descriptions are not optional. Every single page on your Squarespace site has a meta description field under SEO settings. Most people leave it blank. That blank space is wasted real estate — it's the text that appears under your link in search results, and it directly influences whether someone clicks or scrolls past.

Your content needs to answer actual questions. Tools like AnswerThePublic, Google's "People Also Ask" section, and even Reddit threads in your niche show you exactly what your target audience is typing into search bars. Building your page copy around those real questions — not just generic business language — is what actually moves rankings.

Alt text on every image. Squarespace makes it painless to add alt text, yet most people skip it. Search engines can't see your images. Alt text is how you describe them — and it's also how visually impaired users experience your site.

The platform isn't the problem. The strategy is.

2.    Your Template Choice Will Either Limit You or Free You — Choose Carefully

When you first open Squarespace and see those gorgeous templates, it's hard not to just pick the prettiest one and start building. I did exactly that.

Here I will say few people are still using Squarespace 7.0 which is now deprecated version of Squarespace, so humble advice is to shift your website to Squarespace 7.1.

Squarespace 7.1 improved this significantly — all templates now use the same underlying framework, making it easier to switch designs without starting from scratch. But even in 7.1, your template choice sets the initial visual logic, section defaults, and spacing behavior that you'll be working with or fighting against for the life of your site.

Before you choose a template, ask yourself these questions:

What pages do I actually need? A portfolio site needs strong gallery functionality. A service business needs a clear booking or contact flow. A coach or consultant needs a trust-building structure — testimonials, an about section, a visible call to action on every page. Pick a template that already has bones close to what you need, not one that looks pretty but requires you to rebuild its structure from scratch. 

How much customization am I comfortable with?* Some templates are highly minimal and expect you to add your own personality. Others are more opinionated and look great out of the box but feel constrained when you try to deviate. Be honest with yourself about your design skills.

Does it look good on mobile without customization? Pull up the template preview on your phone before committing. The majority of web traffic — across nearly every industry — is now mobile. Mobile devices account for approximately 65% of all global web traffic. If the template requires significant tweaking to look right on a phone, that's hours you didn't budget for.

3.    "Good Enough" Design Is Actively Costing You Clients

This one is uncomfortable to say because Squarespace templates look so polished by default. The bar for "looks fine" is genuinely low. But looking fine and converting visitors into clients are two very different things.

According to a Research, it is found that users form visual impressions of a website in as little as **50 milliseconds** — and those impressions are highly correlated with judgments about credibility, professionalism, and trustworthiness. In other words, your website is being judged before a single word is read.

What kills credibility on Squarespace websites isn't usually bad taste — it's thoughtlessness.

Stock photos that feel generic. You know the ones. Smiling people in business casual pointing at laptops. Hands shaking over a conference table. These images don't just fail to help — they actively signal "I didn't try very hard." Real photos of you, your workspace, your process, or even high-quality contextual stock that feels authentic to your niche will always outperform the obvious choices.

Inconsistent fonts. Squarespace gives you a global font system — once you set your heading, body, and accent fonts, they should carry through the entire site consistently. The moment a visitor sees three different font styles on one page, something in their brain quietly flags "unprofessional," even if they can't articulate why.

Copy that talks about you instead of the client. This is the most common and most damaging mistake I see. "I am a certified life coach with 10 years of experience who helps people achieve their goals" is a sentence about you. "Feeling stuck in a career that no longer fits you? Let's build a path that actually makes sense for your life" is a sentence about them. According to research on web usability, visitors scan for self-relevance — they're asking "is this for me?" within the first few seconds. Your copy needs to answer that question immediately.

No clear call to action. Every page should have one clear next step. Not three. Not a footer navigation menu. One button, one direction, one ask. Book a call. Send a message. Download this guide. The more choices you give people, the less likely they are to take any.

4.    Site Speed Is Not only Technical Problem — It's a Business Problem

I used to think site speed was something only developers needed to worry about. Then I learned that Google has officially used page speed as a ranking factor since 2010, and in 2021 expanded that to include Core Web Vitals — a set of real-world performance metrics measuring loading speed, visual stability, and interactivity.

More importantly: real users leave slow websites. Not someday. Immediately.

Google's own research has found that as page load time increases from one second to three seconds, the probability of a visitor bouncing increases by 32%. At five seconds, that number climbs to 90%.

Squarespace sites are not immune to speed issues. In fact, they're prone to a specific set of problems that most DIY builders create without realizing it.

Images are the number one culprit.  Squarespace does some automatic compression, but it won't save you from uploading a 4MB photograph from your camera roll as a hero background. Before uploading any image to Squarespace, compress it using a tool. Aim for files under 200KB for most images, under 500KB for full-width backgrounds.

Embedded third-party tools slow things down. Every booking calendar widget, social media feed, chat plugin, and external script you add to your Squarespace site adds loading time. Audit what you actually need. If you added a plugin six months ago and never used it, remove it.

Custom fonts from external sources add load time. Squarespace's native font library is large and already optimized for performance. If you're importing a custom Google Font through custom code, make sure you're only loading the weights and styles you actually use.

Use Google PageSpeed Insights to benchmark yourself. It's free, it's accurate, and it gives you specific, actionable recommendations for your actual site. A score above 80 on mobile is a solid target for a Squarespace site.

5.    You Need a Content Strategy Before You Need a Website

This is the hardest one to hear, especially when you're excited about getting your site live.

Most people build their Squarespace website first and then figure out what to say later. They fill placeholder pages with vague descriptions, use the phrase "passionate about helping others" at least three times, and publish with the vague intention of "adding more content soon."

That content never comes. Or it comes months later, as a patchwork of pages that don't feel cohesive and don't serve any clear purpose.

Here's the thing: Google doesn't rank websites. It ranks pages. Specifically, it ranks pages that answer specific questions with genuine depth, demonstrate topical authority, and earn credibility through links and engagement. A beautiful Squarespace site with five thin pages and no blog has almost no surface area for search engines to latch onto.

Before you build, answer these questions:

Who is my ideal visitor, and what are they searching for right before they find me? Get specific. "Small business owners" is not specific. "Female wellness entrepreneurs in the US who want to launch an online coaching program but don't know how to build an audience" is specific.

What are the three to five core services or offerings I want this site to sell? Each one deserves its own dedicated page with real copy — not a bullet point in a list on your homepage.

What content can I create that would genuinely help my ideal client, even before they hire me? This is the basis of a content strategy. A blog post, a free guide, a resource page — anything that provides real value attracts real traffic, builds real trust, and creates the kind of relationship that turns a visitor into an inquiry.

What is the one thing I want every visitor to do? Design your whole site around that action. Everything else supports it.

Squarespace is a genuinely excellent platform. It removes the technical barriers to having a professional-looking website, and for most small businesses, coaches, and creatives, it's more than capable of doing everything you need it to do. But the platform is only as good as the strategy behind it.

The businesses that get consistent traffic, regular inquiries, and real results from their Squarespace websites aren't necessarily the ones with the most beautiful designs. They're the ones who understood SEO before they hit publish, chose their template with intention, wrote copy for their clients instead of themselves, kept their site fast and lean, and built their content with a clear purpose in mind.

If you've already built your site without these things in place — don't panic. Every single one of them can be addressed after the fact. It takes time and intention, but it's absolutely fixable.

And if you haven't built your site yet: you're already ahead of where I was. Use that advantage.

Need help getting your Squarespace website designed, redesigned, or optimized for search? I offer professional Squarespace design, customization, and SEO services on Fiverr — with real strategy behind every decision.

x